Bruce Anderson

Waters of life

Already a subscriber? Log in

This article is for subscribers only

Subscribe today to get 3 months' delivery of the magazine, as well as online and app access, for only £3.

  • Weekly delivery of the magazine
  • Unlimited access to our website and app
  • Enjoy Spectator newsletters and podcasts
  • Explore our online archive, going back to 1828

Hogmanay is pre-Christian, and has no savour of the New Testament; the Scots have always preferred the Old. At Hogmanay, the elements cannot be expected to behave just because there is a star in the sky and the church bells are ding-donging merrily (an even shallower carol). Untamed, nature must be defied. As if to give the forces of darkness time to muster, a proper Hogmanay does not start until -midnight. Thereafter, it is black-avised men struggling along snowy byways, bearing lumps of coal and bottles of whisky. Whisky’s etymology is Gaelic. At Christmas, the English have the way, the truth and the life. At Hogmanay, the Scots have the water of life.

What a water it can be. Recently, I had the pleasure of drinking a bottle of Ardbeg, Committee Reserve. I have never had a finer whisky, and rarely tasted a more expensive one. The Island malts have their detractors. I once heard them described, by a man who is normally sound, as tasting like creosote strained through peat. Although that is rank philistinism, there is an asperity; the first taste is not gentle. I could be persuaded that the normal 17-year-old Ardbeg would benefit from longer in barrel, though one understands the demands of cash-flow. With the Committee Reserve, strength has matured into subtlety: the power is immense, but harmonious.

We were talking about old whiskies, so I told a tale of Brussels during the late Eighties and a restaurant offering ’53 Macallan as an aperitif. That caught my eye as an admirable digestif, especially as it was the same price as a moderate cognac. The first two glasses arrived with ice. We explained that in Scotland, ice in whisky was a criminal offence. While those drams recuperated, we had another couple, and came to the obvious conclusion. Leaving any of that magnificent whisky at the mercy of foreigners who might subject it to abominable indignities: it would be like leaving a wounded man on Afghanistan’s plains.

So we finished the bottle and casually inquired if they had any more (not, I stress, to drink there and then). No, that had been the only one, specially opened for us. It also turned out to have been specially bottled for the Coronation. If one had possessed the foresight to purchase it unopened, it could probably now be exchanged for a case of the Committee Reserve.

There was one trivial problem. I had not been thirsty by the time we started on the whisky, and at nine the next morning, I had a briefing with Arthur Cockfield, then one of the UK Commissioners. The Arthurian legend had an infallible command of detail. The nickname was misleading, for he did not have the mien of rex quondam, rex futurus. He was more like an ancient lizard, and had a relentlessly desiccated voice. One could have done with a more mellifluous companion, especially as he did not offer me so much as a cup of coffee. By the end of the hour, my throat had turned into sandpaper and I needed any old water, urgently, before I could savour in juxtaposition the Arthurian comedy and the previous night’s usquebaugh.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in