Already a subscriber? Log in
The Thornhills move up river where they lay claim to 100 acres of land. They are surrounded by plants and animals they cannot name, and by the shadowy presence of the aboriginal people, whose behaviour they cannot read. The other white settlers are divided in their view of the natives. Kindly Mrs Herring’s acceptance of her strange neighbours has an almost spiritual quality, but drunken Smasher Sullivan hacks off aboriginal hands and ears, and keeps a black woman in chains for his sexual gratification. Which way will the Thornhills go?
Two forces drive William Thornhill — the desire to appease his loyal but homesick wife, and the longing to possess the ground on which he labours. Kate Grenville shows how these desires cannot be fulfilled without the wreaking of huge damage — damage that will rebound to hurt the perpetrator. Ideas about identity, home and ownership, liberty and confinement, are explored in the story of the Thornhills’ battle with their new environment. Grenville’s themes are almost too explicit; she tends to over-explain her characters’ motivations, leaving little work for the reader.
The Secret River has affinities with Barbara Kingsolver’s The Poisonwood Bible, in which an American missionary family struggle uncomprehendingly in the Belgian Congo, but Grenville lacks Kingsolver’s subtle ability to intensify horror through humour, and her characters are less finely delineated. The Thornhills’ predicament is intensely interesting, but they are a wooden lot. All speech is put into italics, which has a flattening effect, as if nothing ever happens at first hand. And there’s just too much hardship, especially in the London section. Sickness, cold, hunger and injustice are piled so high that the whole thing topples over and becomes Pythonesque.
The details of life in the penal colony, however, are fascinating. Rum was a stronger currency than coin, the diet in this land of plenty was salt pork and dried peas, and literacy was almost unknown. Grenville draws on the life of one of her own ancestors to powerful effect; a lot can happen in 200 years. And her evocation of the climate and landscape is excellent. The most interesting character in the novel is that of Australia itself.
Also in Book Reviews
Also by Charlotte Moore
Latest
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in