Already a subscriber? Log in
This is not to say that the books do not vary. Some are more successful than others; some, like Grasshopper or The Blood Doctor strain credulity a little too far: names verge on the fantastical, neighbourhoods are too specific. Perhaps the best — A Dark-Adapted Eye, A Fatal Inversion — belong to a high period which must inevitably pass. Yet the virtues of such unassuming prose are apparent in all her books, and make storytelling rather than professional writing her true calling. I have read most of the Rendells and all of the Vines since first encountering one of her titles in a remote bookshop, quite by chance, many years ago. Her latest offering shows that she has no intention of taking a break, although Minotaur is perhaps the strangest of her books, and the barest.
Swedish Kirsten Kvist goes as an au pair to the Cosway family in Essex, nominally to look after John Cosway, who is perhaps brain-damaged, or schizophrenic, or suffering from the effects of ‘emotional shock’. The household consists of four daughters, three at home and one in London, and their adamantine mother who appears not to care for any of them, least of all her son, to whom she administers a sleeping pill every night and some additional substance during the day. The era is the Sixties, but time seems frozen: only John’s barbiturates and Largactil are of the period. John is in fact autistic, but such a diagnosis would have been unlikely at the time, although now it is almost unavoidable. Equally unlikely are the girls, so-called, although they are in their late thirties. Even odder is the library shaped like a maze and filled with first editions.
The reason why John is force-fed inappropriate drugs is simple: he is the owner of the house and his mother and sisters merely lodgers. It is in their interest, and indeed that of the doctor who supplies the drugs and who is the lover of Mrs Cosway to keep him mute and docile. Readers may understand this a little too readily, but they will be lulled into acquiescence by the story, which is perhaps lacking in tension. It also abounds in clichés: the artist who has rented a house in the village is a Byronic seducer, the depressed eldest daughter wears shapeless cardigans, the rector lacks all insight into human complexity, and the doctor is complaisant. Indeed everyone is complaisant, or ignorant, or incurious, and it is left to plucky Kirsten to connect effect with cause.
In comparison with the earlier novels this is puzzling. It is also perfunctory, the details, even the title, added on rather than intrinsic. The monstrous family, all the more monstrous for being apparently isolated, is unconvincing, as are the fates of the unlikeable characters. Perhaps I have misread what is simply an exercise in Gothick, but I missed the usual urban setting and a level of sophistication normally to be found in this author’s male deviants. Her women, in Minotaur at least, are tiresome rather than troubling. It is an oddly unsituated novel, and I found it uncomfortable. My loyalty to the author, however, remains uncompromised.
Also in Book Reviews
Also by Anita Brookner
Latest
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in