Already a subscriber? Log in
When the likes of Bert Brocklesby applied for unconditional exemption, as they were entitled to under the Act, the local tribunals simply packed them off to join the Non-Combatants Corps which was subsequently ordered to France. The absolutists persisted in their refusal to obey orders, playing into the hands of those in the army’s high command who had been looking for a way of dealing with them because it meant that the men, now technically on active service, could simply be court-martialled for disobedience and shot.
All 35 men were duly tried and sentenced to death — sensationally commuted to ten years’ penal servitude. The absolutists regarded this shock outcome as a victory but, like everybody else, they were unable to account for the last-minute change of heart by the authorities. Ellsworth-Jones reveals that the plan to have the conchies shot, as advocated by Kitchener and Haig, was frustrated as a result of a secret undertaking made by Asquith six weeks earlier to a deputation consisting of Bertrand Russell, the MPs Philip Morrell and Philip Snowden and Catherine Marshall, the organiser of the No Conscription Fellowship, who had anticipated what would happen once the absolutists were sent to France.
In 2006 the British government pardoned all 306 men shot at dawn in the first world war, usually for desertion or cowardice. But for the bloody-mindedness of the 35 ‘Frenchmen’ and Asquith’s intervention on their behalf many others might have faced the firing-squad, men who by any standards were neither cowards nor deserters. As one of the 35, Calder Catchpool, said at his court-martial in October 1917:
I believe England will be honoured in history for having had the courage to introduce exemptions on conscientious grounds — had she not done so, some thousands of us would have been shot, a fate which overtook many under the less liberal regimes of Germany, Austria and Russia.
He tactfully omitted to mention our closest ally, France.
Also in Book Reviews
Latest
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in