Andrew Lambirth

Cross examination

An exhibition of Crucifixions by Craigie Aitchison offers food for contemplation this Easter, says <em>Andrew Lambirth</em>

Already a subscriber? Log in

This article is for subscribers only

Subscribe today to get 3 months' delivery of the magazine, as well as online and app access, for only £3.

  • Weekly delivery of the magazine
  • Unlimited access to our website and app
  • Enjoy Spectator newsletters and podcasts
  • Explore our online archive, going back to 1828

This beautiful little painting is part of a fascinating exhibition of Aitchison’s work at Waddington Custot Galleries (11 Cork Street, W1, until 6 April). All the works on display — some 50 paintings — come from a single private collection, amassed by Sheelagh Cluney, the kind of collector most artists only dream about, who focused her urge to buy paintings entirely on Aitchison. She first saw him, rather drunk with his hair permed in an Afro style and sprayed gold, at the private view of his 1979 museum show at Kettle’s Yard in Cambridge. Cluney bought a painting from that exhibition and went on to become the artist’s most steadfast supporter and patron. She tended to buy work when Aitchison was between dealers, when he especially needed private sales to keep him going, and though she also bought from commercial galleries, she never purchased his work at auction. They became friends and even travelled to Jerusalem together for a British Council exhibition Aitchison was starring in. Cluney was entirely loyal to his work, though she did once mischievously say she might have been tempted to buy something by his friend Euan Uglow — if Craigie had ever introduced her to him…

This exhibition, beautifully installed in the right-hand section of Waddington Custot’s spacious galleries, is an excellent introduction to Aitchison’s work. Since Cluney’s death in 2010, the collection has come on the market and is being dispersed, but the gallery is selling only to private collectors, not to other dealers. This makes much sense, for Aitchison’s work belongs in people’s homes, in an intimate setting, where it will be loved and cherished rather than becoming the subject of financial speculation. He painted certain subjects and themes obsessively: portraits (often of black people because they looked so good against the strong-coloured backgrounds he favoured), still-lifes, landscapes and religious pictures. Aitchison loved dogs and he also painted his Bedlingtons, often including one of them in his crucifixions, as a silent and moving witness to the great event. There are some very fine paintings on show: among the portraits, ‘Patrice Felix Tchicaya III’ and ‘Patrick Conyngham’ (on a black background), while ‘Liquorice Allsorts Still-Life’ is a superb example of a different genre. But it is with the religious paintings that we are principally concerned here.

The smaller room at the back of the gallery is like a private chapel hung with paintings for contemplation and devotion. One of Cluney’s largest purchases, a huge Crucifixion from 1984, occupies the main wall, an image of desolation and unblinking austerity, with a lonely Christ lost in a waste of earth-brown paint, comforted only by a bird — perhaps the dove of peace or the Holy Spirit itself. However, as is usual with Aitchison, a note of optimism is struck. The purple mountain above has a golden glow and sprouts a tree with delicate pink foliage in token of the possibility of redemption. Tragedy has come to the world, but we are not left without hope.

To the right of this magisterial painting is a group of three other crucifixions, of which ‘Crucifixion with Mountain’ is the most poignant. Its companions offer different settings: a green and gentle place where Christ is attended by a recumbent sheep and a pair of seagulls, and a dark starlit night — Christ in his agony against the depthless sky. Aitchison imbues each with a different emotional charge. Some of the strangeness and haunting ethereal quality to Aitchison’s crucifixions undoubtedly derives from his habit of painting them as if they were still-life subjects of the utmost spirituality. He never used a human model for his Christ on the Cross (unlike artists down the ages), but often referred to existing paintings of the Italian Renaissance masters he admired, or to his collection of religious artefacts. He owned various devotional crucifixes and hung a Holy Water stoup in his hallway.

Whether you’re motivated by faith, doubt or the desire to see good paintings, the Aitchison exhibition is very highly recommended. And if you live in or near Wales, a further show entitled Risen! Art of the Crucifixion and Eastertide, at Monnow Valley Arts (Middle Hunt House, Walterstone, Hereford, until 21 April, but check opening times), is well worth a visit. It features treasures from the Methodist Church Collection of Modern Christian Art, including an extraordinarily powerful ‘Crucifixion’ by William Roberts, previously owned for 40 years by Augustus John, and a richly coloured ‘Supper at Emmaus’ by Ceri Richards. The Methodist gems are juxtaposed with a selection of work by younger artists, among whom Andrea McLean and Mark Cazalet seem to me to offer the most food for spiritual thought and contemplation. May your Easter be a joyful one, and not just a feast of chocolate eggs.

Andrew Lambirth’s A is a Critic: writings from The Spectator, published by Unicorn Press, is available from new.spectator.co.uk/lambirth at £9.99 (plus p&p).

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in