Michael Tanner

Exalted by Beethoven

Fidelio

Already a subscriber? Log in

This article is for subscribers only

Subscribe today to get 3 months' delivery of the magazine, as well as online and app access, for only £3.

  • Weekly delivery of the magazine
  • Unlimited access to our website and app
  • Enjoy Spectator newsletters and podcasts
  • Explore our online archive, going back to 1828

When they emerge, thanks to the unsanctioned initiative of Leonore/ Florestan (this in contravention of the text), they look as if they have strayed from One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, dressed immaculately in white suits, a few of them stripped to the waist, and obviously having access to the prison’s fitness suite. It’s not easy to see why there should be these departures from verisimilitude, but given the general quality of the performance it’s best not to make too much of them. What makes them odder is that the style both of the costumes and sets, and of the acting, is mainly naturalistic; or something between silent-movie style and what passes for naturalism. At times it even seemed as if Flimm was getting his performers to send up that style. All the singers are thoroughly competent actors, so it is unclear why they lapse at intervals into hamming. Unclear, too, why such experienced players of these roles should speak the dialogue in such a stilted fashion, and even more why there should be so many departures from the familiar text, which for those who adore the work is almost as sacred as the music.

The incredibly moving words of Rocco and Fidelio when they appear after Florestan has sung his aria — Endrik Wottrich gave a harrowingly anguished and inward account of it, and brought off its climax as few tenors manage to — were both truncated and altered, and fitted in poorly with the simple instrumental phrases which normally punctuate them. More important, all references to Providence (eine Vorsehung) are removed, yet, however much we might prefer that, Leonore is emphatic in telling Florestan to remain calm because Providence will see that everything turns out for the best. That is of course a blatant falsehood, yet nothing else will account for the famous trumpet signalling the Minister’s arrival just when it is most needed. You can’t rationalise the plot of Fidelio. And it is only when you have got some distance from the impact of an adequate performance that you feel the need to.

Perhaps that is the paradox that Flimm is working on: to impress us as it needs to, this opera must seem plausible, despite the cross-dressing of its heroine. Yet it also requires a transcendental benign power as well as the earthly if somewhat lackadaisical one of Don Fernando. But the way out of that is not to mix genres, so that some of the time the characters seem to be pawns or caricatures, and elsewhere they are everyday agents. The Don Pizarro of Terje Stensvold is excellently sung, and he is cast as a gruesome manager, just right. Yet he also indulges in melodramatic behaviour so absurd I was afraid it would evoke laughter, fatal to this work.

No fear of that when Karita Mattila, now at the height of her powers, appeared. She was in stupendous form, even if it’s a pity that her voice is not slightly fuller. Everything she did and sang bore the stamp of conviction, and she is as convincingly young-mannish as any Leonore I’ve seen. Rocco is played by Eric Halfvarson as a lovable, almost moronic old buffer, which dodges the issue of his venality, but his singing is in the great tradition of dark basses in this role. Antonio Pappano’s conducting, which often tends to extremes of dynamics and tempo, was traditional in those respects, could even have done with more abandon, and more swing — in the Act I trio, the dungeon quartet, and the finale. But I went out into the sodden streets exalted by the passion and integrity of Beethoven’s vision, and grateful for so forceful a reminder of the values which should inform political and social life, but never do.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in