Already a subscriber? Log in
So, it’s ironic that the resignation of Sir Paul Stephenson is now being used by some to question the coalition’s plans for elected Police & Crime Commissioners (PCCs). These figures would replace Police Authorities – invisible and costly committees of appointees – with a single directly-elected personality, who would provide civilian oversight of the police.
Opponents have been propagating scare stories about extremist candidates and other bogus arguments for months. Equally, many of the policing establishment continue to make a constitutional argument about politicisation of the police. The Association of Chief Police Officers has lobbied hard to defend the status quo under the banner of the office of constable and on numerous occasions has implied that this is somehow under threat from an elected Police Commissioner.
But it is precisely because we need to keep politics out of policing that PCCs are such a necessary reform. By respecting the operational independence of the police, they will serve to insulate the chief constable from politics, liberating police officers to fight crime. And an elected Police Commissioner is effectively a public safety mayor, who will help to hold the police to account, ensuring that local people get the sort of policing they deserve.
Crime-fighting is what matters most to the police, and the reputation of organisations like the Metropolitan Police ultimately rests on the ability of the police to do just that. The Met is an
organisation that, by virtue of its importance and size, attracts a lot of scrutiny. But like the New York Police Department in the early 1990s which had completely lost its way, the Met too often
seems to have an overriding objective to avoid external criticism, not to fight crime. Scotland Yard has become an increasingly political place over the last decade; the senior management has
established close relations with the media to defend their reputation. That is not the task of a police force.
It would be naive to expect the police to operate in a bubble. The Crime Reporters’ Association will still expect some privileged access, earned by their members’ own discretion and
experience. And, of course, chief constables should maintain formal relations with the media and always have a direct line to the public in times of crisis. But close relations with buddies in the
press is the preserve of politicians. So let those who are elected and accountable for politics judge them on that. But let the professionals, the chief constables, get on with fighting crime and
disorder. Only police reform to create elected Police Commissioners can restore the police to their proper role.
Blair Gibbs is the Head of Crime & Justice at Policy Exchange
Because you read about coalition
Also by Blair Gibbs
Latest
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in