What happened to the Rishi Sunak I knew at school?
Another agnostic, Matthew Arnold, wrote in very similar terms. George Eliot herself, on a visit to Oxford in the year she was writing Middlemarch, was taken out to see the ‘monastery’ at Littlemore where Newman had lived in retreat before becoming a Catholic, and she expressed huge admiration for him more than once in her letters. Lord Rosebery, one day to become the Liberal Prime Minister, and no Catholic, met Newman at Norfolk House (the Duke of Norfolk’s London house) when the great man was 79 and felt the attraction: ‘He is much younger looking than his photographs, less wrinkled, has a deliciously soft voice and manner’.
Everyone mentioned the beguiling voice, which had held Oxford enthralled during the 1830s. When Newman died, and Rosebery was a great political figure, he took the train to Birmingham to see Newman laid out on the High Altar of the Oratory:
This was the end of the young Calvinist, the Oxford don, the austere vicar of St Mary’s. It seemed as if a whole cycle of human thought and life were concentrated in that august repose.
Nor should one forget Newman’s spellbinding posthumous influence on the poets of the Nineties — and Ezra Pound’s amusing poem about the death of Lionel Johnson, who had fallen off a pub stool, ‘But showed no trace of alcohol/At the autopsy, privately performed —Tissue preserved – the pure mind/Arose toward Newman as the whisky warmed’. Does this count as a miracle?
Edward Short’s Dance to the Music of Time cast-list includes Gladstone, R. H. Hutton (editor of The Spectator), various Arnolds and Wilberforces, Lord Palmerston and of course the Cardinals Wiseman and Manning. There is a good chapter on Newman and Arthur Hugh Clough. My chief disappointment was that I do not think he went into enough detail about the Froude family. Hurrell Froude, with his pretty little-boy cherub looks was in a way Newman’s first big love. When Hurrell died, the notebooks he left behind — Froude’s Remains — caused scandal by showing just how High he had been, how close to Rome in his distaste for the poor old C of E. Newman published the Remains deliberately as a bomb in a supermarket, to cause mayhem in the Oxford Common Rooms. Hurrell’s brother James Anthony Froude was a keen New-maniac until he grew up. Then he put all that behind him and became a disciple of Carlyle.
I’d have liked more about J.A.Froude — he increasingly seems to me the most impressive of all the Victorian intellectuals. But this book has a strong Roman Catholic bias, which is especially discernible in the chapter on Pusey. No matter. It is difficult to discard a point of view if you have one.
I am not sure that it entirely lives up to the promise of a Victorian Dance to the Music of Time. I think D. J. Taylor would be better qualified to write that. This book, however, with its rich cast-list and broad sweep, will be a valued addition to the libraries not only of the Newmaniacs but of anyone who takes the 19th century seriously and who wishes to explore its often alien ideas and characters.
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in